It´s always been a matter of eye color and skin tone for makeup in my case as well. For example, I know that I generally stay away from the reds and darker pinks because they make my skin look like it´s broken out/reddened/ whatever.And some purples look like I´ve gotten punched in the eye. So that´s also a matter of trying out a dash of color on your lids one day, and going through all the colors and seeing which you like best on you. (for example, my mom can´t stand orange-ish eyeshadow. It doesn´t look bad on her, per se, but she hates it).
As for the other colors, I use them pretty varied (:P Yes, I admit that I have light brown hair!! *LoL*).......one of the color combos I like to use best is a darker matte brown on the outer edge of my eye, with a coppery color as the lid color and a beigy-golden tone (it´s beige but with slightly gold sparkles? >.< I have no idea how to express this) for my tear duct area. I think that the three brownish tones that you have in the top eyeshadow (the ones between the pink and the purple) would work quite nicely. Or for a less exaggerated one, the three you have in the bottom tier of the lower right corner eyeshadow thing. >
With your lovely eye color, though, I´d love to see that aqua blue with a light purple shade on your eyes.... _< You´d look so pretty, and your eye color would really stand out, I bet.
Not that I know a lot about makeup either.....I got interested when I first started on MAF and have paid really close attention to all the makeup gurus we have here. :D
@Evig: Thanks for the tip....I´ve been looking for somewhere that sold something for my eyebrows not in pencil shape...but somehow that´s impossible to find in my area....